Better Lovers, the metal band formed from the ashes of Every Time I Die, has announced a significant change in its lineup. The band confirmed on Tuesday, February 24, 2026, that it is separating from its lead singer, Greg Puciato. This decision marks a new chapter for the group, which quickly gained recognition since its formation in 2023.
The announcement came via the band's official social media channels. While the news might surprise some fans, both the band and Puciato have stressed that the split is amicable, urging fans not to speculate about any underlying conflict.
Key Takeaways
- Better Lovers and Greg Puciato have officially parted ways.
- The band is currently writing a new album and seeking a new vocalist.
- Both parties confirm the split is amicable, with no bad blood.
- Puciato was featured on two Better Lovers releases: "God Made Me an Animal" (2023) and "Highly Irresponsible" (2024).
A New Direction for Better Lovers
The metal quartet, based in Buffalo, New York, made the public statement on Instagram. Their message was direct and clear: "Better Lovers is parting ways with Greg Puciato. We’re proud of the work we’ve done together but we are moving in another direction." This statement signals a strategic shift for the band as they look to define their sound and future trajectory.
The remaining members—guitarists Jordan Buckley and Will Putney, bassist Stephen Micciche, and drummer Clayton Holyoak—are now focused on their next creative endeavor. They have confirmed that work on a new album is already underway.
"To all of our fans, thank you for riding with us these past few years. We’ve accomplished so much in such a short time with your support and we’re still beyond excited to continue down this road with you," the band shared in their Instagram post. "The four of us are finishing writing a new album which we are extremely proud of and currently looking for a new singer. Thanks for your understanding, we’ll see you soon."
Quick Fact
Better Lovers formed in 2023, bringing together members from the acclaimed band Every Time I Die after its disbandment.
Puciato's Perspective on the Split
Greg Puciato, known for his powerful vocals and dynamic stage presence, also addressed the separation. He used his personal Instagram Story to reassure fans and prevent rumors from circulating. His message echoed the band's sentiment of a peaceful parting.
"No bad blood. Everyone’s cool. Don’t speculate," Puciato wrote. This clear statement aims to manage fan expectations and maintain a positive atmosphere around both his future projects and Better Lovers' continued journey. He expressed gratitude for his time with the group, stating, "Love these people and love the band. Rooting for them all collectively and individually. Thanks everyone for making the last few years special. Long live the frog."
Collaborations and Releases
During his tenure with Better Lovers, Greg Puciato contributed to two notable projects. In 2023, he was featured on "God Made Me an Animal." The following year, 2024, saw the release of "Highly Irresponsible," which served as the band's official debut album. These releases helped establish Better Lovers as a significant force in the metal scene.
Band Origins
Better Lovers emerged following the end of Every Time I Die, a band that left a lasting impact on the metalcore genre. The formation of Better Lovers, with a lineup featuring former Every Time I Die members, generated considerable excitement among fans eager for new music from these accomplished musicians.
Looking Ahead: A New Vocalist Search
With a new album in the works, the search for a new lead vocalist is now a primary focus for Better Lovers. This process is critical for the band, as the new singer will undoubtedly shape their evolving sound and public image. Fans are keenly awaiting updates on who will step into this pivotal role.
The band's recent social media activity, just weeks before this announcement, painted a picture of camaraderie and enjoyment. A February 12 Instagram post highlighted their positive experiences while touring in Australia.
- The band described Australia as their "favorite" country to tour, despite the long travel.
- They expressed gratitude to both long-time fans and new faces who attended their shows.
- The post mentioned that Better Lovers had been "petal to the metal for almost three years now," indicating their intense work ethic.
This previous post also hinted at new material, stating, "It’s going to feel nice to ease our feet off the gas ever so slightly and decide what to do with these 22 files marinating in this ‘new songs’ folder." This suggests a significant amount of new music has been in development, which will now move forward with a new vocal presence.
The Future of Better Lovers
The next few months will be crucial for Better Lovers as they navigate this transition. Finding a new voice that aligns with their musical direction and maintains the energy fans expect will be a key challenge. However, the band's commitment to new music and their appreciative message to fans suggest a strong desire to continue their artistic journey.
The metal community will be watching closely to see who joins the ranks of Better Lovers and what new sounds emerge from this refreshed lineup. The departure of a lead singer often marks a significant turning point, and for Better Lovers, it signals a bold step into an unwritten future.
Band Members
Better Lovers consists of Jordan Buckley (guitar), Will Putney (guitar), Stephen Micciche (bass), and Clayton Holyoak (drums).
The band has reiterated its gratitude to fans for their unwavering support throughout their initial years. Their message emphasized excitement for the road ahead, indicating confidence in their ability to evolve and continue creating impactful music. This positive outlook, despite the lineup change, sets an optimistic tone for their future endeavors.